Mulhall, Terry (1988) The politics of Irish history: transition in Ireland: modernization or underdevelopment. Master of Arts thesis, Dublin City University.
Abstract
The first chapter situates debate on social change in Ireland within the context of the debate on the transition. There are three aspects of this, the economic, the political and the cultural, which provide three themes running through each chapter. I begin by situating Ireland within the international socio-political context. The economic expansion in Ireland is related to the international expansion and the the emergence of revisionism is related to the emergence of modernization theory. This is to say that the basic characteristics of the Irish situation are related to the international one.
I then go on to situate these factors within the larger
historical context of the development of capitalism and the
emergence of bourgeois political economy. The reversal of social change in Ireland is in turn described and related to the international situation. This international situation has promoted the development of a neo-Marxist theory of imperialism as a critique of modernization. The terms of this critique are outlined in terms of mode of production and the conditions for the transition. This sets the scene for the second chapter.
The second chapter deals with the debate on the transition from feudalism to capitalism. On an empirical level the case of the transition in England is used. The basic characteristics of the feudal mode of production in England are described. Following this the process of historical change is described and within the context of the theoretical debate an attempt is made to locate the determining influences. The debate basically turns upon
whether commercialization or class conflict was the determining factor. The evidence in comparison to other countries would seem to suggest that the transformation of class relations was the decisive factor.
Having clarified this issue the next step is to look at Ireland historically within the context of this transition. This involves firstly a reconstruction of the mode of production in Ireland prior to colonization and secondly a delineation of the new mode of production which resulted from a merger with the embryonic capitalist mode. On the basis of the theory of transition we can then set out to explain how the social relations of colonial society obstructed the conditions whereby capital accumulation could take place. The social relations which forced an increase in relative surplus value were not created. Instead the commercialization of society saw a huge increase in output and upon this increase a rentier class developed. In the north-east social relations were different and thus also the form of economic development.
Chapter four examines how the accumulation of industrial
capital created areas of different levels of productivity. In Britain the increase in relative surplus value led to a
concentration and centralization of production and a massive
expansion of output. In Ireland, on the other hand, the social relations enabled no increase in absolute surplus value and created no capital accumulation. The fall in the rate of surplus value reduced the share of surplus available for peasants whicheventually lead to a famine followed by mass emigration and a restructuring of Irish agriculture. This created the social conditions for the Irish land war.
The dual structure which modernization theorists take to be
evidence of transition is explained in terms of this question of
surplus value. In the North-East social conditions led to an
increase in relative surplus value and an accumulation of
capital. The logic of concentration and centralization which this
involved eventually led to industrialization. This created a
further element in the opposition to nationalism.
Chapter five looks at the movement towards the secession of
Ireland from Britain within the context of Imperialism or Finance
Capital. The logic of industrial concentration and centralization
led to the development of national trusts and created intense
national rivalry. This led to an international conflict in 1914
and to a subsequent break-up of empires. Ireland was part of this
process. The effect of this industrial concentration on Irish
agriculture was the centralization of certain agricultural
processes combined with the creation of peasant proprietorship.
This provided the social basis for the war of independence. In
the North-east, on the other hand, capital accumulation had meant
a closer integration of the economy and society into 'Britain
which culminated in the successful opposition to Republicanism.
Chapter six brings the debate up to the era of the
multinationals and Ireland's reintegration into the international
economy. The major feature here is the move away from the export of primary products to the export of manufactured goods through
multinational companies. The effect of this was a
commercialization of the economy without the creation of the
conditions of capital accumulation. The logic of capital
accumulation marginalized Irish industry rather than
revolutionizing it. The result was that in the next phase of
concentration Ireland was effectively bypassed.
Metadata
Item Type: | Thesis (Master of Arts) |
---|---|
Date of Award: | 1988 |
Refereed: | No |
Supervisor(s): | Gibbons, Luke |
Uncontrolled Keywords: | Ireland Politics and government; Social change in Ireland |
Subjects: | Social Sciences > Communication Social Sciences > Political science |
DCU Faculties and Centres: | DCU Faculties and Schools > Faculty of Humanities and Social Science > School of Communications |
Use License: | This item is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. View License |
ID Code: | 19100 |
Deposited On: | 03 Sep 2013 10:19 by Celine Campbell . Last Modified 03 Sep 2013 10:19 |
Documents
Full text available as:
Preview |
PDF
- Requires a PDF viewer such as GSview, Xpdf or Adobe Acrobat Reader
4MB |
Downloads
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year
Archive Staff Only: edit this record