Socially Responsible Investments (SRI) have recently generated much interest amongst asset owners, managers and academicians. Though the Efficient Market Theory suggests that stock prices fully reflect all available information, few existing studies indicate that ESG portfolios deliver superior risk-adjusted performance. ESG investing is at a nascent stage in India but is growing rapidly, especially after the COVID-19 pandemic. Asset managers always face the dilemma of choosing between different screening methods, screening intensities and stock weighting schemes to deliver outperformance. Our study attempts to investigate the impact of these portfolio construction criteria on the risk-adjusted performance of ESG portfolios in India. Our results show that there exists a trade-off between superior investment performance and unsystematic risk of ESG portfolios. Investors can benefit from investing in equally-weighted bestin-class portfolios constructed using ESG scores. We highlight the implications of our findings for asset owners, managers, index providers and regulators, and also provide directions for future research in the area of ESG portfolio management.